The fall is the time for great local apples. One of my neighbors is a farmer with a small orchard. He had 1/2 peck bags of Fugi apples out on his cart for $4 per bag. I picked up 2 bags of apples to make my favorite apple product, apple butter. I love the sweetness of the apples, mixed with a bit of a bite from the cinnamon and cloves. To me, this is what apples were made for.
Since I was off work today, I decided it was time to make up a batch of apple butter. Here’s the base recipe that I found on the National Center for Home Food Preservation. It is a great place to start. Last time I made this, I got 6 pints out of the batch. I want a little more, so I increased my number of apples to almost 9 pounds but left the rest of the recipe alone.

Apple butter ingredients
- 8 lbs apples
- 2 cups apple cider
- 2 cups cider vinegar
- 2 1/4 cup sugar
- 2 1/4 cup brown sugar
- 2 tbsp cinnamon
- 1 tbsp ground cloves

Apples cooking
Wash, core and cut up the apples. Cook the apples in the apple cider and the vinegar over low heat until they are soft. This took me the better part of an hour.

Straining the apples
When I didn’t feel the resistance of uncooked apples while stirring, I figured they were soft enough to strain. To me that means into the antique food mill that my mother gave me. It is a bit of work, but the wooden plunger fits the contours of the strainer perfectly. My only complaint about this mill is the base doesn’t fit inside the pots I use to process various food.

Cooking down the apple butter
Once strained, this goes into a big pot with the sugars and spices. This is cooked down to a thicker consistency. I test for the proper thickness by using the plate method. Spoon a little of the apple butter onto a white plate. If a big ring of liquid forms, it isn’t thick enough. I like my apple butter slightly thinner, so I allow a small ring of liquid eventually forming around the apple butter.

Apple butter processed
Once thick enough, I ladle the finished apple butter into sanitized wide mouth jars, leaving about 1/2″ head space. Put on sterilized lids and tighten down the bands. These then go into a boiling water bath canner. Process pints and half pints for 5 minutes. If doing quarts, process those for 10 minutes.

Cottage cheese with apple butter
Here’s my favorite way to eat my apple butter. A bowl of cottage cheese with a generous serving of apple butter on top. It doesn’t get any better than this.